My First try Editing a Weap

On the custom weapon, the outline on the blade is WAYYY too thick.
MapleStory weapons have a strict 1-black pixel outline rule. so dim that down and it'll look much better.

Also, I see what you're going for with the whole Cloud+KH thing going on there, but that handle is way to thick, break it down a little, even though it'll seem like you can't hold it. It's best so it doesn't look all bulgy on the hand.
And also get rid of all that grey chicken scratch I see in there. Choose your base colour for the blade, a darker version of that for the back of the blade, only a slim part though, to make it look natural, and a lighter version of the original base colour to give it a nice even strip of shine so it looks as though the sun is beaming off from it.


I won't comment on the other weapon cause it only looks like you changed the hue randomly through the inside of it.